.
Feedback

In Search of The Old Leather Man, Part I

A mysterious figure, the Leather Man, inspired curiosity everywhere he went.

Dressed all in leather with a leather pack and tin pail, the peripatetic Leather Man wandered in a regular path between the Connecticut and Hudson Rivers making the trip once every 34 or 35 days.

He first came to the notice of the local press in 1869 and by the time his wanderings became predictably regular in 1883, he had become a local legend whose appearance in town were anticipated, noted, and commented on.

His identity was unknown. Although some reports claimed he was the love lorn Jules Borglay, doing penance for a love affair gone wrong in his home in southern France, he in fact, rarely ever talked and then only in monosyllabic answers to questions, so his identity as Borglay was highly unlikely. 

Dan W. Deluca, whose recent book The Old Leather Man , has effectively proved the Leather Man could not have been Borglay and that we really do not know who he was.  Even his identity as French was in question.

His wandering stopped in March of 1889 when he was found dead in one of his rock shelter dwellings in Mount Pleasant, NY, just north of Ossining. Throughout the prior year it had been reported he had exhibited signs of lip cancer that had spread to his lower jaw and a coroner’s inquest confirmed this was the cause of his death.

At public expense, he was buried in a simple pine box supplied by the Ossining Funeral home of White Dorsey in the pauper’s section of the Sparta cemetery just off Route 9 in Ossining.

Partially as a result of the mystery surrounding this local legend, there was a recent attempt to locate his grave and disinter his remains by the Historical Society of Ossining.

In addition to learning something about his identity, a more compelling reason was to move his grave site away from the very busy highway where the increasing volume of visitors to his grave were in danger of fast moving local traffic. 

The plan, then, was to find his body and rebury it in a central and more prominent location about 150 feet away from his original resting place.

Little did I, or others involved in the process, know what we would find.

Editor's note: Read the rest of Dan Cruson's first-person account at ""

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Newtown Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Terri Bhatt June 4, 2011 at 08:32 pm
Very interesting article. As a Monroe resident and former Ossining native, I'm curious to hear what happened next!
Jane Goode June 4, 2011 at 10:37 pm
My Dad used to tell us about this man. We lived in Greenwich/North Stamford and he (my Dad) knew some of the people who's estates he lived on. We were told that he was welcome to stay in these places, was very courteous, and kept to himself. He was in no way a 'nuisance' as modern day hobo's are considered. There is a small 'museum' at the Ward Pound Ridge Reserve that has a small section dedicated to Leatherman since that was one of his regular stay-over spots.
Jane Goode June 4, 2011 at 10:40 pm
I wasn't aware that he went as far as Ossining. That's impressive.... quite a distance to walk.
Craig Zac June 5, 2011 at 02:49 am
I read he used to hide pennies outside of the schools for the kids to search for or something like that... he was probably just some homeless guy who had "Issues" but was friendly and harmless but just had no one in his life to help him out. Poor guy, he seemed happy though, from what is reported pn him.
Don Goodrich June 5, 2011 at 02:43 pm
For twenty-five years, as an English teacher in Stamford, I always taught my students about the Leatherman as part of an American Folklore unit. At that time he was thought to be Jules Bourglais from France. Recently this has supposedly been proven false by undisputed evidence. I never heard what this "undiisputed evidence is. Any of the research I did on him seemed to strongly support the story of him being a forlorn lover who lost his French fiance to a poor investment made for her father's business forcing him out of the family. This I still believe to be the identity of the Leatherman. Can anyone explain the facts that discount this theory?
Jane Goode June 5, 2011 at 08:44 pm
Don, I was also told the same story about Leatherman. In fact, I was told that he was some sort of a leathersmith in France, hence his ability to sew his leather clothing. I don't know what evidence there is to dispute this story. I'm glad there are others keeping the story of Leatherman alive. I was always transfixed by his legend....
Don Goodrich June 5, 2011 at 09:03 pm
Jane,
There was a book published about a year ago where I first heard this nixing of the Jules Bourglais story but there was no explanation in the book either just more mystery. Yes he was a leathersmith in France and was working for his fiance's father's leather business, made some bad investments and bankrupted the father, hence leaving France to "punish" himself for ruining his future father in law's business. There seemed to be alot of evidence supporitng this unfortunately all those who knew him or the story first hand are long dead.
Jane Goode June 6, 2011 at 12:13 am
Thanks for that! I wonder if we'll ever really know who he was....
Craig Zac June 6, 2011 at 12:26 am
I think the whole "forlorn lover from France leather worker, bad investment, bankrupt, fatherinlaw story just sounds too contrived. Either he made it up and told folks that or it was just folklore... i mean its believed the leather man didn't really talk much more than but in monosyllable answers, and if he came here from France, who then got him to talk that much to get his story? To me it just sounds like all those other urban legends.. the woman who waits for her dead husband and / or son to come home by sitting in her window with one lamp on... or the homeless guy who walks around and everyone says he is really a multi-millionaire who just lives like a homeless man. Every neighborhood has one..
Jane Goode June 6, 2011 at 01:08 am
Very true. Having a son with Asperger's, who speaks very little (by choice), I can see that he probably did have Autism. I guess we'll never really know, unless they are able to locate his grave, and do whatever tests need to be done to determine how he died, etc. I wonder where the author of the book on Leatherman got all his info.
Don Goodrich June 6, 2011 at 11:22 am
Craig, it is true the Leatherman spoke only in grunts and monosyllabic "words" and only in French. What I have read is that his backround was researched by people who had been contact with him and observed his behaviors and skills. Imagine what might have been discovered with our hitech search capabilities today. He is a true "folk legend" and we will probably never know the actual truth. Just the fact that this character was local makes it more intriguing for us who live here. Going to his cave in Pound Ridge Reservation has such an eerie feeling. It is unfortunate that more wasn't attempted to find his story when those who met him were still alive.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Thomas Paine June 18, 2013 at 01:47 pm
Why is it the panel for this event does not include a single advocate for gun-owners' rights? WithRead More all due respect to Chief McNamara, why does the panel no include a person who can speak to gun safety from a gun-owning civilian's perspective? ML, you claim that the assembled folks "do not offer judgements about gun ownership" but they are not including a single voice that can offer perspective on gun ownership. I have been to "education" sessions sponsored by Meg's March for Change and they are one-sided indoctrinations into gun control advocacy. >>>> I was in Hartford for the public hearings in January when both Meg and March co-founder Nancy gave their personal testimonies and they all but threatened the legislators on the panel with election day retribution for all those who did not tow the gun-control line of thinking (i.e. March and CAGV). To suggest that Meg "does not offer judgements" is fallacious and disingenuous.
DOR June 19, 2013 at 08:56 am
I'm o n Butterfield. No sightings here. Any specifics as to her location?
Carol Chapman June 19, 2013 at 09:23 am
Norma has been spotted this morning at the intersection of Kenan and Currituck. The red leash isRead More still attached. She was trying to eat a dead squirrel on Currituck. Very skittish, but still in the neighborhood (yay). Please watch for her. My husband and sister-in-law (who first spotted her on Currituck this morning) were unable to get near her. She's in the woods, heading toward Butterfield. Her foster mom is on the scene now. Folks in the neighborhood, please watch for her and call 203-942-4008 if you see her.
Carol Chapman June 19, 2013 at 11:20 am
Carolee Mason (Newtown's Animal Control Officer) is watching her from her car at the moment, armedRead More with catfood to tempt her closer. The foster mom is on her way there again, this time with chicken, and Laura is on her way with hamburger. Problem is, this dog is VERY shy, skittish and quick to run away.
Betsy Kraushaar June 17, 2013 at 07:54 am
If you have goodies left that you are interested in donating to our Girl Scout Troop...pleaseRead More contact me. Our troop has been saving/ fundraising for a senior trip to Europe for the past 5 years. Thanks in advance, Betsy
Llyod Christmas June 17, 2013 at 09:01 pm
Hi Betsy! We have tons of children's books left, and would be more than happy to donate them. HowRead More should I get in touch with you to drop them off?
Betsy Kraushaar June 17, 2013 at 10:46 pm
Lloyd, My email is betsykraushaar@charter.net....I'd love to get some books...Thanks!!!
Every Friday, Rain or Shine, Lone Activist Stands
Elissa Bass June 14, 2013 at 08:44 pm
I do too.
Amy Pare June 16, 2013 at 09:28 am
This is amazing. Where is she standing?